Dietary Quote by Tim Noakes
““The US dietary guidelines were the first ever to inform the general public about what should not be eaten. Specifically, we were told to avoid fat, especially saturated fat, and to replace dietary saturated fats with carbohydrates and polyunsaturated ‘vegetable’ (actually seed) oils. Failure to do so, we were warned, would cause us all to die of heart attacks, because cholesterol, we were told, causes coronary heart disease. Instead, the advice drove us down the road to obesity and the much more severe form of arterial disease caused by T2DM. Some have described this monumental error as the greatest scam in the history of modern medicine. The fallout has produced some very big ‘winners’, specifically those pharmaceutical companies that have benefited from the sale of the largely ineffective statin drugs, and the processed-food industry, dominated by 10 companies that produce the ‘displacing foods of modern commerce””
About This Quote
Source Speech: Public health commentary, 2010s
The guidelines mistakenly vilified fat, leading to high-carb diets, obesity, diabetes, and a lucrative statin and processed‑food industry.
In simple terms: Bad dietary advice caused health crises and profit for pharma and food giants.
Key Takeaway
Question low‑fat diets; prioritize whole foods.
Themes
nutrition
public health
industry influence
misinformation
policy
health economics
Mood
critical
concerned
inquisitive
Type
analysis
commentary
When to use this quote
- public health policy
- personal diet planning
- medical education
- regulatory reform
Key Concepts
dietary guidelines
fat vs carbs
cholesterol myth
statin drugs
processed foods
Questions to Reflect On
- How might we redesign guidelines using unbiased evidence?
- What policies can curb profit‑driven health misinformation?
A Different Perspective
The guidelines were based on incomplete science and industry pressure.
![“There is good evidence that Aborigines are genetically insulin resistant,94 so that some of their metabolic traits ‘are associated with being Aboriginal (mild impairment of glucose tolerance, hyperinsulinemia and elevated total and VLDL [very low density lipoprotein] triglycerides)’.95 In such a…” quote by Tim Noakes](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/12e/tim-noakes-12730_food-choices_there-is-good-evidence-that-aborigines-a_522275.jpg)
![“In contrast to the positive associations for total and dietary calcium, there was no association with intake of nondairy calcium. This result might have suggested that other components of dairy products than calcium contribute to [prostrate cancer] risk.” quote by Dagfinn Aune](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/744/dagfinn-aune-108790_calcium_in-contrast-to-the-positive-associations_1309064.jpg)
