Brother Quote by Mark Twain
“Such is professional jealousy; a scientist will never show any kindness for a theory which he did not start himself. There is no feeling of brotherhood among these people. Indeed, they always resent it when I call them brother. To show how far their ungenerosity can carry them, I will state that I offered to let Prof. H--y publish my great theory as his own discovery; I even begged him to do it; I even proposed to print it myself as his theory. Instead of thanking me, he said that if I tried to fasten that theory on him he would sue me for slander.”
About This Quote
Source Letter: Private correspondence, 1890s (source unknown)
Scientists may with a to own ideas, showing jealousy and lack of collegiality.
In simple terms: Scientists can be jealous and unkind about others’ theories.
Key Takeaway
Promote collaboration and give credit where due.
Themes
professionalism
jealousy
collaboration
Mood
critical
analytical
Type
ethical
philosophical
When to use this quote
- research labs
- academic conferences
- grant proposals
- peer review
Key Concepts
intellectual property
ethics
academic culture
Questions to Reflect On
- What incentives encourage sharing ideas?
- How can institutions reduce professional envy?
A Different Perspective
Collaboration can be hindered by ego and fear of being eclipsed.
