Black Quote by Lynn Austin
“Shebna scraped the tablet clean and began drawing circles in the soft clay. "Suppose you had six figs and you ate two. How many would--" "Four." Hezekiah answered before Shebna finished, and the tutor's thick black eyebrows rose in surprise. "And suppose I had five figs. How many would we--" "Nine." "Have you done this before?" Hezekiah thought the question was ridiculous. "I've eaten figs lots of times.”
About This Quote
A teacher uses a misleading math problem to illustrate how assumptions can lead to absurd answers, highlighting the importance of clear reasoning.
In simple terms: Assumptions can produce nonsense answers.
Question hidden premises.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- classroom
- problem solving
- debate
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- What assumptions are you overlooking?
- How can you clarify questions?
If the premise is flawed, the conclusion is meaningless.