Decision making Quote by Keith E. Stanovich
““In cognitive science, the tendency to give different responses to problems that have surface dissimilarities but that are really formally identical is termed a framing effect. Framing effects are very basic violations of the strictures of rational choice. In the technical literature of decision theory, the stricture that is being violated is called descriptive invariance-the stricture that choices should not change as the result of trivial rewordings of a problem.2 Subjects in framing experiments, when shown differing versions of the same choice situation, overwhelmingly agree that the differences in the problem representations should not affect their choice. If choices flip-flop based on problem characteristics that the subjects themselves view as irrelevant-then the subjects can be said to have no stable, well-ordered preferences at all. If a person's preference reverses based on inconsequential aspects of how the problem is phrased, the person cannot be described as maximizing expected utility. Thus, such failures of descriptive invariance have quite serious implications for our view of whether or not people are rational.””
About This Quote
Source Book: Thinking, Fast and Slow, Daniel Kahneman, 2011
People often change choices when the same problem is phrased differently, showing irrationality in decision making.
In simple terms: Framing changes decisions despite identical facts.
Beware of wording effects.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- marketing
- policy design
- personal finance
- legal arguments
- education
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How does framing influence your daily decisions?
- Can you identify a recent choice affected by wording?
People may still make rational choices if they recognize and adjust for framing.