Communication Quote by James McGrath Morris
““Berkman called no witnesses of his own. Instead, with the aid of an ill-trained interpreter, he began to read his long speech. “Some may wonder why I have declined a legal defense,” Berkman said. “My reasons are twofold. In the first place, I am an anarchist: I do not believe in man-made laws, designed to enslave and oppress humanity. Secondly, an extraordinary phenomenon like an attentat cannot be measured by the narrow standards of legality.” In short, Berkman said, he would explain the deed, and by doing so, society itself would be put on trial. An hour into his presentation, much of which was heard only in mangled English, Judge McClung’s patience came to an end. He ordered Berkman to finish by the rapidly approaching hour of one o’clock. “I can have all the time I want for my defense and will take all the time I need,” Berkman replied. “No, you haven’t,” said the judge. “We’ll teach you different if you think you can dictate to us.” Berkman and his interpreter sputtered on. At 1:10 the judge stopped Berkman and gave the prosecutor the floor. Holding the dagger in his hands, he urged the jury to convict Berkman. The jury didn’t even stir from the box. It immediately pronounced Berkman guilty on all counts. McClung sentenced him to 22 years of confinement.””
About This Quote
Source Book: The Man Who Knew Too Much by James McGrath Morris, 2009
Berkman rejects legal defense, arguing that an anarchist’s act challenges societal laws and forces a broader moral trial.
In simple terms: He refuses to defend himself within the legal system, seeking a societal reckoning.
Challenge authority, demand moral scrutiny.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- courtroom
- political protest
- public trial
- media coverage
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- Can law ever truly judge moral transgressions?
- What alternatives exist for confronting unjust laws?
Legal systems may not accommodate radical dissent.