Death Quote by Machado de Assis
““The next day, he read to me a freshly composed dirge in which the circumstances of his wife’s death and burial were commemorated. He read it in a voice quavering with emotion, and the hand that held the paper was trembling. When he had finished, he asked me whether the verses were worthy of the treasure that he had lost. “They are,” I said. “They may lack poetic inspiration,” he remarked, after a moment’s hesitation, “but no one can deny them sentiment—although possibly the sentiment itself prejudices the merits…” “Not in my opinion. I find the poem perfect.” “Yes, I suppose, when you consider…Well, after all, it’s just a few lines written by a sailor.” “By a sailor who happens to be also a poet.” He shrugged his shoulders, looked at the paper, and recited his composition again, but this time without quavering or trembling, emphasizing the literary qualities and bringing out the imagery and music in the verses. When he had finished, he expressed the opinion that it was the most finished of his works, and I agreed. He shook my hand and predicted a great future for me.””
About This Quote
Source Novel: Dom Casmurro by Machado de Assis, 1899
A sailor poet reads a heartfelt dirge about his wife's death, questioning its artistic worth, while others debate sentiment versus technical merit.
In simple terms: A poet worries if his sad poem is good enough; others defend its feeling.
Value honesty and emotion in creative work.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- grieving
- literary criticism
- creative confidence
- peer feedback
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How do you balance feeling and technique in art?
- When should emotion outweigh form?
Sentiment can cloud objective assessment of craft.