Skip to content

Book review Quote by Alistair Campsie

“is to certify that someone so far unidentified wrote deliberate errors into the corrected final proofs of this book after they left my hands, then stole the proofs and the typescript, presumably to avoid detection from their hand-writing. These errors were picked up by me in the advance copies and…” quote by Alistair Campsie
Download Open image
““is to certify that someone so far unidentified wrote deliberate errors into the corrected final proofs of this book after they left my hands, then stole the proofs and the typescript, presumably to avoid detection from their hand-writing.     These errors were picked up by me in the advance copies and I immediately phoned the publishers, Canongate, and wrote the same day, July 18, 1980, giving details for an errata slip, which they promised to post out to everyone who had received a review copy.     The most dangerous errors were that a Seumas MacNeill's name had been given three incorrect spellings, which, as I feared, appeared to incense him, as he deeply resented any mis-spelling of his name, indicating the person responsible well knew of him.     He maturely retaliated in his Piping Times (Nov, 1980), at the age of 63, by mis-spelling my name five different ways and also mis-spelled the publisher's name in a "book review" signed Seumas MacNeill, He then distributed his magazine throughout the U.K., Europe, the Commonwealth and the U.S.A., asserting to the piping world the book was totally inaccurate, an allegation he was also permitted to make on BBC,””

Alistair Campsie

About This Quote

Source Letter: Errata notice to Canongate, July 18 1980

An author discovered deliberate errors in proofs, leading to a public correction and a retaliatory mis‑spelling dispute.

In simple terms: Errors were found and corrected after theft.

Key Takeaway

Ensure rigorous proofreading and protect manuscript integrity.

Themes

integrity accountability literary ethics conflict

Mood

cautious analytical

Type

professional educational

When to use this quote

  • academic publishing
  • book reviews
  • author-publisher relations
  • error correction

Key Concepts

Proofreading publishing process reputation management

Questions to Reflect On

  • How can authors safeguard against tampering?
  • What steps ensure accurate publishing?
A Different Perspective

Retaliation can damage professional relationships.

3.2 out of 5 (5 ratings)

More by Alistair Campsie

Explore all 12 Alistair Campsie quotes

More Book review quotes

Browse all 79 Book review quotes