Evolution Quote by Robert M. Sapolsky
““Study a gene in only one environment and, by definition, you’ve eliminated the ability to see if it works differently in other environments (in other words, if other environments regulate the gene differently). And thus you’ve artificially inflated the importance of the genetic contribution. The more environments in which you study a genetic trait, the more novel environmental effects will be revealed, decreasing the heritability score. Scientists study things in controlled settings to minimize variation in extraneous factors and thus get cleaner, more interpretable results—for example, making sure that the plants all have their height measured around the same time of year. This inflates heritability scores, because you’ve prevented yourself from ever discovering that some extraneous environmental factor isn’t actually extraneous.fn22 Thus a heritability score tells how much variation in a trait is explained by genes in the environment(s) in which it’s been studied.””
About This Quote
Source Lecture: Stanford University Biology Course, 2015
Studying a gene in only one setting hides how environment changes its effect, inflating perceived genetic influence.
In simple terms: Only one environment hides environmental impact on genes.
Test genes across varied conditions.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- plant growth studies
- human disease genetics
- agricultural breeding
- climate impact research
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How would conclusions shift in diverse settings?
- What environmental factors could be overlooked?
Results may still be limited by unmeasured variables.