Skip to content

Hands and feet Quote by M.R. James

“But it was in the life-saving competition that Stanley Judkins's conduct was most blameable and had the most far-reaching effects. The practice, as you know, was to throw a selected lower boy, of suitable dimensions, fully dressed, with his hands and feet tied together, into the deepest part of…” quote by M.R. James
Download Open image
““But it was in the life-saving competition that Stanley Judkins's conduct was most blameable and had the most far-reaching effects. The practice, as you know, was to throw a selected lower boy, of suitable dimensions, fully dressed, with his hands and feet tied together, into the deepest part of Cuckoo Weir, and to time the Scout whose turn it was to rescue him. On every occasion when he was entered for this competition Stanley Judkins was seized, at the critical moment, with a severe fit of cramp, which caused him to roll on the ground and utter alarming cries. This naturally distracted the attention of those present from the boy in the water, and had it not been for the presence of Arthur Wilcox the death-roll would have been a heavy one. As it was, the Lower Master found it necessary to take a firm line and say that the competition must be discontinued. It was in vain that Mr. Beasley Robinson represented to him that in five competitions only four lower boys had actually succumbed. The Lower Master said that he would be the last to interfere in any way with the work of the Scouts; but that three of these boys had been valued members of his choir, and both he and Dr. Ley felt that the inconvenience caused by the losses outweighed the advantages of the competitions. Besides, the correspondence with the parents of these boys had become annoying, and even distressing: they were no longer satisfied with the printed form which he was in the habit of sending out, and more than one of them had actually visited Eton and taken up much of his valuable time with complaints. So the life-saving competition is now a thing of the past.””

M.R. James

About This Quote

The narrative condemns a dangerous, staged rescue competition that caused injury and death, highlighting the moral failure of its organizer and the need for ethical oversight in youth activities.

In simple terms: Exposes reckless competition harming children

Key Takeaway

Ethical responsibility outweighs tradition

Themes

ethics youth safety authority abuse institutional negligence tradition vs progress

Mood

concerned critical reflective

Type

historical anecdote moral warning

When to use this quote

  • school sports events
  • boy scout activities
  • historical school competitions
  • parental complaints

Key Concepts

dangerous practices leadership accountability child welfare

Practical Applications

  • policy reform in youth programs
  • safety training redesign

Questions to Reflect On

  • What safeguards should be mandatory in youth competitions?
  • How can institutions balance tradition with safety?
A Different Perspective

Some may argue the competition taught resilience, but the lethal risk outweighs any educational benefit.

4.4 out of 5 (4 ratings)

More by M.R. James

Explore all 5 M.R. James quotes

More Hands and feet quotes

Browse all 183 Hands and feet quotes