Skip to content

Health care Quote by John R. Lott Jr

“The Army psychiatrist who last saw Ivan Lopez found no “sign of likely violence, either to himself or to others.”42 James Holmes’s psychiatrist warned the University of Colorado officials about her patient’s violent fantasies, but she “rejected the idea” that the threat was sufficiently serious…” quote by John R. Lott Jr
Download Open image
““The Army psychiatrist who last saw Ivan Lopez found no “sign of likely violence, either to himself or to others.”42 James Holmes’s psychiatrist warned the University of Colorado officials about her patient’s violent fantasies, but she “rejected the idea” that the threat was sufficiently serious for him to be taken into custody.43 Seung-Hui Cho, the Virginia Tech killer, was subject to a commitment hearing.44 However, licensed psychologist Roy Crouse performed an independent evaluation and found Cho to be “mentally ill” but concluded, “he does not present an imminent danger to (himself/others) . . . he does not require involuntary hospitalization.” A staff psychiatrist at Carilion St. Albans Psychiatric Hospital recommended outpatient counseling and determined that Cho “is not a danger to himself or others.” The judge accepted these findings and determined not to have Cho involuntarily committed.45 These mass killers certainly didn’t lack mental health care. The problem was that even top psychiatrists failed to identify them as real threats.””

John R. Lott Jr

About This Quote

Even expert mental‑health evaluations can miss imminent danger, highlighting limits of risk assessment.

In simple terms: Psychiatric assessments can fail to predict violence.

Key Takeaway

Improve detection methods and take warnings seriously.

Themes

mental health risk assessment public safety

Mood

cautious critical

Type

analytical policy

When to use this quote

  • clinical practice
  • law enforcement
  • policy making

Key Concepts

diagnostic limitations preventive policy

Questions to Reflect On

  • What safeguards can prevent such oversights?
  • How can we balance rights and safety?
A Different Perspective

Over‑reliance on expert opinion may delay intervention.

2.3 out of 5 (8 ratings)

More by John R. Lott Jr

Explore all 71 John R. Lott Jr quotes

More Health care quotes

Browse all 2,420 Health care quotes