Empiricism Quote by John Dewey
““Empirically, things are poignant, tragic, beautiful, humorous, settled, disturbed, comfortable, annoying, barren, harsh, consoling, splendid, fearful; are such immediately and in their own right and behalf… These traits stand in themselves on precisely the same level as colours, sounds, qualities of contact, taste and smell. Any criterion that finds the latter to be ultimate and "hard" data will, impartially applied, come to the same conclusion about the former. -Any- quality as such is final; it is at once initial and terminal; just what it is as it exists. it may be referred to other things, it may be treated as an effect or a sign. But this involves an extraneous extension and use. It takes us beyond quality in its immediate qualitativeness… The surrender of immediate qualities, sensory and significant, as objects of science, and as proper forms of classification and understanding, left in reality these immediate qualities just as they were; since they are -had- there is no need to -know- them. But... the traditional view that the object of knowledge is reality par excellence led to the conclusion that the object of science was preeminently metaphysically real. Hence, immediate qualities, being extended from the object of science, were left thereby hanging loose from the "real" object. Since their -existence- could not be denied, they were gathered together into a psychic realm of being, set over against the object of physics. Given this premise, all the problems regarding the relation of mind and matter, the psychic and the bodily, necessarily follow. Change the metaphysical premise; restore, that is to say, immediate qualities to their rightful position as qualities of inclusive situations, and the problems in question cease to be epistemological problems. They become specifiable scientific problems; questions, that is to say, of how such and such an event having such and such qualities actually occurs.””
About This Quote
Argues that sensory qualities are as fundamental as physical data, urging a shift from metaphysical abstraction to treating immediate qualities as scientific objects of study.
In simple terms: Sensory qualities deserve scientific status.
Reframing immediate qualities as data resolves epistemological disputes.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- designing experiments that measure subjective experience
- redefining research variables to include sensory data
- challenging traditional object‑centred models
Key Concepts
Practical Applications
- human‑centered AI design
- multimodal perception research
Questions to Reflect On
- How can we operationalize subjective experience for empirical study?
- What implications does this shift have for interdisciplinary research?
Critics may argue that subjective qualities lack reproducibility and thus cannot serve as reliable scientific data.