Affront Quote by George Weigel
![“By the same token, the new and stringent Ultramontanism on the Catholic Left - in which even the mildest questions about how things are working in this pontificate are denounced as treasonous disloyalty - is an affront to the open conversation for which the pope [FRANCIS] has called.” quote by George Weigel](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/e10/george-weigel-9372_affront_by-the-same-token-the-new-and-stringent_1885252.jpg)
“By the same token, the new and stringent Ultramontanism on the Catholic Left - in which even the mildest questions about how things are working in this pontificate are denounced as treasonous disloyalty - is an affront to the open conversation for which the pope [FRANCIS] has called.”
About This Quote
Source Book: The Pope and the People, George Weigel, 2022
The quote criticizes a rigid, dogmatic stance within the Catholic Left that labels any questioning of the papacy as disloyal, opposing Pope Francis’s call for open dialogue.
In simple terms: Rigid dogma stifles honest discussion.
Key Takeaway
Encourage respectful questioning.
Themes
religion
dialogue
authority
politics
faith
Mood
critical
thoughtful
concerned
Type
analytical
commentary
theological
When to use this quote
- parish meetings
- theological debates
- media interviews
- academic conferences
Key Concepts
Ultramontanism
institutional critique
church governance
Questions to Reflect On
- How can the Church balance openness with doctrinal integrity?
- What role should dissent play in faith communities?
A Different Perspective
Such criticism may overlook the need for doctrinal unity and can be perceived as undermining church authority.
![“It's pretty much what a lot of committed Catholics are making of [Pope Francis]. They're thrilled, they're refreshed, they think it's a breath of fresh air.” quote by Ralph Martin](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/ac6/ralph-martin-40430_air_it-s-pretty-much-what-a-lot-of-committed_1624441.jpg)
![“I think [Pope] Francis intends to forge ahead with his reform agenda.” quote by Sylvia Poggioli](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/5ea/sylvia-poggioli-32511_agendas_i-think-pope-francis-intends-to-forge-ah_391785.jpg)
![“But ripped out of context, ["Who am I to judge?" phrase] has become an all-purpose filter through which everything else - including the pope's multiple reaffirmations of Humanae Vitae, Paul VI's encyclical on the morally appropriate means of family planning - gets airbrushed out of the picture.” quote by George Weigel](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/b1d/george-weigel-9372_appropriate_but-ripped-out-of-context-who-am-i-to-ju_146817.jpg)
![“I hope ["reanimated the papacy"] means that the new interest in the pope evokes a new interest in the Church's teaching, of which the pope is the custodian.” quote by George Weigel](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/a8e/george-weigel-9372_church_i-hope-reanimated-the-papacy-means-that_225548.jpg)
![“The pope [Francis] takes his vocabulary from his pastoral experience, not from the rhetorical tool kit of liberation theology, with its Marxist yammering about "center" and "periphery." The "peripheries," for Francis, are all those who have fallen through the cracks of late-modernity and…” quote by George Weigel](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/14f/george-weigel-9372_argentina_the-pope-francis-takes-his-vocabulary-fr_261899.jpg)
![“[Pope Francis]sees a world in need of the Gospel, and of friendship with Jesus Christ, as an antidote to the self-absorption and loneliness that are eating away at the solidarity of the human community.” quote by George Weigel](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/79d/george-weigel-9372_absorption_pope-francis-sees-a-world-in-need-of-the_343248.jpg)
![“[Pope] Francis communicates the pastoral embrace of the Church, the breadth and inclusiveness of Catholicism symbolized by the Bernini colonnade around St. Peter's Square, in a powerful way.” quote by George Weigel](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/06a/george-weigel-9372_bernini_pope-francis-communicates-the-pastoral-e_495970.jpg)
