Therapist Quote by Edward Teyber
““In fact, the same intervention or response may even have the opposite effect on two different clients with contrasting developmental histories and cultural contexts. For example, if a client’s parent was distant or aloof, the therapist’s judicious self-disclosure may be helpful for the client. In contrast, the same type of self-disclosure is likely to be anxiety-arousing for a client who grew up serving as the confidant or emotional caregiver of a depressed parent. Greater sharing with the therapist may help the first client learn that, contrary to her deeply held beliefs, she does matter and can be of interest to other people. In contrast, for the second client, the same type of self-disclosure may inadvertently impose the unwanted needs of others and set this client back in treatment as, in her mind, she experiences herself back in her old caretaking role again—this time with the therapist. This unwanted reenactment occurs because the therapeutic relationship is now paralleling the same problematic relational theme that this client struggled with while growing up.””
About This Quote
Source Book: Clinical Social Work Practice (2nd ed.) by Edward Teyber and Faith Hogan, 2015
Therapeutic self‑disclosure can help or hinder clients depending on their developmental and cultural backgrounds; what works for one may retraumatize another.
In simple terms: Self‑disclosure benefits vary by client history.
Tailor therapist self‑disclosure to each client’s relational patterns.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- counseling sessions
- cultural competency training
- case supervision
- client intake assessments
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How do you assess a client’s readiness for therapist self‑disclosure?
- What safeguards prevent reenactment of past relational patterns?
Over‑disclosure can reinforce maladaptive roles.