Autism Quote by Darian Leader
““Campaign to destigmatize so-called "mental illness" often take a wrong turning here. They try to demonstrate how suffers of some condition have made amazing contributions to the science or the arts. Trying to destigmatize the diagnosis of autism, for example, we read how Einstein and Newton would have received that diagnosis today, and yet made fabulous discoveries in the field of physics. Even if they are acknowledged to have been "different", their worth is still reckoned in terms of how their work has impacted on the world of others. However well-intentioned, such perspectives are hardly judicious, as they make an implicit equation between value and social utility. Taking this step is dangerous, as the moment that human life is defined in terms of utility, the door to stigmatization and segregation is opened. If someone was found to be not useful, what value, then, would their life have? This was in fact exactly the argument of the early-twentieth-century eugenicists who complained for the extermination of the mentally ill. Although no one would admit such aspirations today, we cannot ignore the resurfacing in recent years of a remarkably similar discourse, with its emphasis on social utility, hereditary and genetic vulnerability.””
About This Quote
Source Essay: Opinion piece on mental health stigma, author unknown, 2023
The argument warns that linking a person's worth to their social utility, even when trying to reduce stigma, can echo eugenic thinking and justify discrimination against those deemed “unproductive.”
In simple terms: Equating value with usefulness can lead to new forms of stigma and discrimination.
Avoid defining human worth solely by productivity.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- policy debates
- education curricula
- advocacy campaigns
- media representation
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How can we celebrate neurodiversity without reducing it to utility?
- What alternative frameworks respect dignity beyond productivity?
Such framing may unintentionally reinforce harmful stereotypes and overlook intrinsic human worth.