Skip to content

Causal Quote by Daniel Kahneman

“Regression effects are ubiquitous, and so are misguided causal stories to explain them. A well-known example is the “Sports Illustrated jinx,” the claim that an athlete whose picture appears on the cover of the magazine is doomed to perform poorly the following season. Overconfidence and the…” quote by Daniel Kahneman
Download Open image
““Regression effects are ubiquitous, and so are misguided causal stories to explain them. A well-known example is the “Sports Illustrated jinx,” the claim that an athlete whose picture appears on the cover of the magazine is doomed to perform poorly the following season. Overconfidence and the pressure of meeting high expectations are often offered as explanations. But there is a simpler account of the jinx: an athlete who gets to be on the cover of Sports Illustrated must have performed exceptionally well in the preceding season, probably with the assistance of a nudge from luck—and luck is fickle. I happened to watch the men’s ski jump event in the Winter Olympics while Amos and I were writing an article about intuitive prediction. Each athlete has two jumps in the event, and the results are combined for the final score. I was startled to hear the sportscaster’s comments while athletes were preparing for their second jump: “Norway had a great first jump; he will be tense, hoping to protect his lead and will probably do worse” or “Sweden had a bad first jump and now he knows he has nothing to lose and will be relaxed, which should help him do better.” The commentator had obviously detected regression to the mean and had invented a causal story for which there was no evidence. The story itself could even be true. Perhaps if we measured the athletes’ pulse before each jump we might find that they are indeed more relaxed after a bad first jump. And perhaps not. The point to remember is that the change from the first to the second jump does not need a causal explanation. It is a mathematically inevitable consequence of the fact that luck played a role in the outcome of the first jump. Not a very satisfactory story—we would all prefer a causal account—but that is all there is.””

Daniel Kahneman

About This Quote

Source Article: Intuitive Prediction, co‑author unknown, 2015

Regression to the mean causes extreme outcomes to be followed by more average ones, yet people often invent causal stories to explain this natural statistical tendency.

In simple terms: Extreme results tend to be followed by average ones; we create stories to explain it.

Key Takeaway

Accept statistical explanations over invented narratives.

Themes

statistics human bias causality probability misinterpretation

Mood

skeptical analytical curious

Type

explanatory observational

When to use this quote

  • sports analysis
  • financial forecasting
  • medical diagnostics
  • education assessment

Key Concepts

regression to the mean confirmation bias overconfidence

Questions to Reflect On

  • How often do you attribute random variation to personal agency?
  • What evidence would convince you a causal story is valid?
A Different Perspective

Statistical explanations may ignore real causal factors that could be actionable.

3.8 out of 5 (6 ratings)

More by Daniel Kahneman

Explore all 560 Daniel Kahneman quotes

More Causal quotes

Browse all 7 Causal quotes