Skip to content

If an inmate swears at a guard, fights, or hides…

“If an inmate swears at a guard, fights, or hides contraband like cigarettes or candy [Sheriff Arpaio has banned coffee, cigarettes, hot lunches, girlie mags & TV], she's kicked out of the tents and sent to lockdown--a tiny cell 10x12 feet that houses 4 women, instead of the 2 it was built for…” quote by Jane Evelyn Atwood
Download Open image
““If an inmate swears at a guard, fights, or hides contraband like cigarettes or candy [Sheriff Arpaio has banned coffee, cigarettes, hot lunches, girlie mags & TV], she's kicked out of the tents and sent to lockdown--a tiny cell 10x12 feet that houses 4 women, instead of the 2 it was built for. There's no tv, no phone, & no a/c. Even though most of these women have drug problems, programs like NA or AA are considered 'privileges' forbidden to those locked down. The only way to get out of lockdown is to volunteer for the chain gang--the first & only female chain gang in the United States (as of Aug 1997). Volunteers sign a paper that says they know & accept the conditions on the chain--cleaning Phoenix streets, painting the center strip of miles of highway, & burying AZ's indigent. The accusation of 'cruel & unusual punishment' is quashed by the argument that the chain gang is purely voluntary. After all, if you prefer, you can spend the whole year in lockdown.””

Jane Evelyn Atwood

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Lockdown conditions are harsh; voluntary chain‑gang labor is presented as a remedy, raising ethical concerns.

In simple terms: Harsh prison policies force labor under guise of choice.

Key Takeaway

Critique punitive systems, demand humane reform.

Themes

justice human rights prison reform ethics policy

Mood

critical advocacy

Type

Incarcerated-women:1 Incarceration:1 Lockdown:1 Phoenix:0 Women-in-prison:1 Chain Gang:1 Way Lockdown:0 Lockdown Tiny:0 Az Indigent:0

When to use this quote

  • court hearings
  • advocacy campaigns
  • policy reviews

Key Concepts

coercive labor systemic abuse civil liberties

Questions to Reflect On

  • How can prisoners exercise true choice?
  • What alternatives exist to punitive lockdown?
A Different Perspective

Voluntary labor may still be exploitative.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More Incarcerated-women quotes

Browse all 2 Incarcerated-women quotes