Theory Quote by Walter Isaacson
““After three weeks of lectures and receptions in New York, Einstein paid a visit to Washington. For reasons fathomable only by those who live in that capital, the Senate decided to debate the theory of relativity. Among the leaders asserting that it was incomprehensible were Pennsylvania Republican Boies Penrose, famous for once uttering that “public office is the last refuge of a scoundrel,” and Mississippi Democrat John Sharp Williams, who retired a year later, saying, “I’d rather be a dog and bay at the moon than stay in the Senate another six years.” On the House side of the Capitol, Representative J. J. Kindred of New York proposed placing an explanation of Einstein’s theories in the Congressional Record. David Walsh of Massachusetts rose to object. Did Kindred understand the theory? “I have been earnestly busy with this theory for three weeks,” he replied, “and am beginning to see some light.” But what relevance, he was asked, did it have to the business of Congress? “It may bear upon the legislation of the future as to general relations with the cosmos.” Such discourse made it inevitable that, when Einstein went with a group to the White House on April 25, President Warren G. Harding would be faced with the question of whether he understood relativity. As the group posed for cameras, President Harding smiled and confessed that he did not comprehend the theory at all. The Washington Post carried a cartoon showing him puzzling over a paper titled “Theory of Relativity” while Einstein puzzled over one on the “Theory of Normalcy,” which was the name Harding gave to his governing philosophy. The New York Times ran a page 1 headline: “Einstein Idea Puzzles Harding, He Admits.””
About This Quote
Source Book: Einstein: His Life and Universe by Walter Isaacson, 2007
The story illustrates how even top leaders can be baffled by complex scientific ideas, yet they must still make policy decisions that may be affected by those ideas.
In simple terms: Leaders often lack deep understanding of scientific concepts that influence policy.
Seek expert advice before deciding on science‑related policies.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- Congressional debates
- presidential decision‑making
- media coverage
- public misunderstanding
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How can policymakers better integrate scientific expertise?
- What mechanisms ensure accurate scientific communication to legislators?
Leaders may ignore expert counsel, leading to misguided policies.