Advice Quote by Thomas McEvilley
“Many modern scholars have found the asceticism expressed in Plato unacceptable; it does not sound like the advice of a reasonable man in the Cartesian tradition.”
About This Quote
The quote critiques Plato’s ascetic ideals as incompatible with rational, Cartesian thought, suggesting they lack practical moral guidance.
In simple terms: Plato’s self‑denial conflicts with logical, everyday reasoning.
Key Takeaway
Question philosophical teachings against modern rational standards.
Themes
philosophy
critique
ethics
Mood
analytical
critical
Type
philosophical
scholarly
When to use this quote
- academic debate
- ethical decision‑making
- personal discipline
- spiritual practice
Key Concepts
asceticism
Cartesian rationalism
Platonism
Questions to Reflect On
- What modern values clash with ancient philosophies?
- Can asceticism be reconciled with rationalism?
A Different Perspective
Plato’s ideas may still hold symbolic value despite logical objections.
