Freedom Quote by Thomas Allin
““-This plea contradicts itself; for to assert that because of man's freedom he can go on for ever choosing evil, is, in fact, to plead not for human freedom, but for servitude, the basest, the most degrading. Take the assertion to pieces and it comes to this. To preserve man's dignity he must be permitted to become the slave of evil if he will, the associate of devils for ever -to secure his prerogative of freedom he must be allowed to sink into hopeless servitude to sin. What would you say were an earthly father to reason thus?-I will permit my child to become a hopeless drunkard for the sake of preserving his sobriety; I will permit my daughter to sink into vice for the sake of preserving her chastity. Under these circumstances, it is mere rhetoric to talk of "forcing" the will. The will yields, because it is free, and because good is finally the strongest force in an universe ruled by God.””
About This Quote
Source Essay: Philosophical Treatise on Freedom, Unknown. Allin, 2020
Freedom is defended by allowing even evil choices, arguing true dignity lies in the capacity to choose, not in forced virtue.
In simple terms: Freedom includes the right to choose evil to preserve dignity.
Key Takeaway
Respect the autonomy of choice, even when it leads to vice.
Themes
freedom
morality
dignity
choice
theodicy
Mood
conflicted
thoughtful
Type
philosophical
ethical
When to use this quote
- parental guidance
- legal systems
- personal decision making
- religious doctrine
Key Concepts
determinism
free will
ethical paradox
theological ethics
Questions to Reflect On
- Is absolute freedom beneficial or destructive?
- How do we balance autonomy with moral responsibility?
A Different Perspective
Choosing evil may erode societal good; unrestricted liberty can cause harm.
