Constitutional convention Quote by Steve Kluger
““ Alexander Hamilton Junior High School -- SEMESTER REPORT -- STUDENT: Joseph Margolis TEACHER: Janet Hicks ENGLISH: A, ARITHMETIC: A, SOCIAL STUDIES: A, SCIENCE: A, NEATNESS: A, PUNCTUALITY: A, PARTICIPATION: A, OBEDIENCE: D Teacher's Comments: Joseph remains a challenging student. While I appreciate his creativity, I am sure you will agree that a classroom is an inappropriate forum for a reckless imagination. There is not a shred of evidence to support his claim that Dolley Madison was a Lesbian, and even fewer grounds to explain why he even knows what the word means. Similarly, an analysis of the Constitutional Convention does not generate sufficient cause to initiate a two-hour classroom debate on what types of automobiles the Founding Fathers would have driven were they alive today. When asked on a subsequent examination, "What did Benjamin Franklin use to discover electricity?" eleven children responded "A Packard convertible". I trust you see my problem. [...] Janet Hicks Parent's Comments: As usual I am very proud of Joey's grades. I too was unaware that Dolley Madison was a Lesbian. I assumed they were all Protestants. Thank you for writing. Ida Margolis””
About This Quote
A teacher’s report highlights a student’s academic excellence but criticizes inappropriate, unfounded claims and classroom disruptions.
In simple terms: Student excels academically but misbehaves with wild theories.
Key Takeaway
Encourage curiosity while setting clear boundaries.
Themes
education
discipline
creativity
Mood
critical
concerned
Type
analytical
advisory
When to use this quote
- school projects
- debates
- research assignments
Key Concepts
critical thinking
academic integrity
classroom management
Questions to Reflect On
- How can teachers channel creativity productively?
- What policies balance freedom and order?
A Different Perspective
Overemphasis on discipline may stifle creative thinking.
![“[James] Madison pointed out in the discussion of the constitutional debates - the constitutional convention - that democracy would be a danger. He used England of course as the model and said suppose that in England everyone had the free right to vote; the poor, the propertyless - who are the…” quote by Noam Chomsky](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/069/noam-chomsky-42_constitutional-conve_james-madison-pointed-out-in-the-discuss_22456.jpg)
