Constitutional convention Quote by Andrew McCarthy
““The delegates to the Constitutional Convention were adamant that impeachment not reach to errors of judgment, or what Edmund Randolph described as “a willful mistake of the heart, or an involuntary fault of the head.” On the other hand, betrayals of the constitutional order, dishonesty in the executive’s dealing with Congress, and concealment of dealings with foreign powers that could be injurious to the rights of the people were among the most grievous high crimes and misdemeanors in the Framers’ estimation.””
About This Quote
Source Document: The Federalist Papers, No. 65, 1788
The Framers wanted impeachment to target serious betrayals, not simple mistakes or poor judgment.
In simple terms: Impeachment should punish grave breaches, not minor errors.
Key Takeaway
Focus on serious misconduct.
Themes
government
law
ethics
Mood
cautious
critical
Type
historical
analytical
When to use this quote
- legislative oversight
- executive misconduct
- foreign influence
- public trust
Key Concepts
constitutional intent
political accountability
Questions to Reflect On
- What defines a “grave breach” in modern politics?
- How can safeguards prevent partisan abuse?
A Different Perspective
Impeachment can be politicized, risking misuse against dissent.
![“[James] Madison pointed out in the discussion of the constitutional debates - the constitutional convention - that democracy would be a danger. He used England of course as the model and said suppose that in England everyone had the free right to vote; the poor, the propertyless - who are the…” quote by Noam Chomsky](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/069/noam-chomsky-42_constitutional-conve_james-madison-pointed-out-in-the-discuss_22456.jpg)
