Books Quote by Richard J. Evans
““Some authors have argued that a direct historical line can be drawn to Nazism from the French Revolution of 1789, the Jacobin 'Reign of Terror' in 1793-4, and the implicit idea of a popular dictatorship in Rousseau's theory of the 'General Will,' decided initially by the people but brooking no opposition once resolved upon. The French Revolution was indeed remarkable for its rehersal of many of the major ideologies that bestrode the historical stage of Europe in the following two centuries, from communism and anarchism to liberalism and conservatism. But National Socialism was not among them. The Nazis, indeed thought of themselves as undoing all the work of the French Revolution and rolling back the clock, in a political sense at least, much further to the early Middle Ages. Their concept of the people was racial rather than civic. All the ideologies to which the French Revolution had given birth were to be destroyed. The Nazi Revolution was to be the world-historical negation of its French predecessor, not its historical fufillment.””
About This Quote
Source Book: “The Coming of the Third Reich” by Richard J. Evans, 2003
The French Revolution’s ideas about popular sovereignty differed fundamentally from Nazi racial nationalism, making a direct historical line inaccurate.
In simple terms: French Revolution and Nazis are not a straight line.
Recognize distinct ideological roots.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- academic study
- political analysis
- education
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- What factors differentiate civic from racial concepts of “the people”?
- How does this affect modern political discourse?
Simplifying complex histories can lead to misconceptions.