Skip to content

Butchers Quote by Jonathan Swift

“Physicians ought not to give their judgment of religion, for the same reason that butchers are not admitted to be jurors upon life and death.” quote by Jonathan Swift
Download Open image
“Physicians ought not to give their judgment of religion, for the same reason that butchers are not admitted to be jurors upon life and death.”

Jonathan Swift

About This Quote

Source Essay: A Modest Proposal, 1729

Physicians should not judge religion, just as butchers shouldn't serve as jurors in life‑and‑death cases.

In simple terms: Doctors shouldn't mix faith with medical judgment.

Key Takeaway

Separate professional expertise from personal belief.

Themes

ethics profession religion

Mood

critical thoughtful

Type

ethical philosophical

When to use this quote

  • medical practice
  • legal testimony
  • public policy
  • ethical training

Key Concepts

secularism judgment professional boundaries

Questions to Reflect On

  • Should personal beliefs ever inform professional advice?
  • How to ensure impartiality in critical decisions?
A Different Perspective

Complexities of personal belief influencing decisions.

3.8 out of 5 (4 ratings)

More by Jonathan Swift

Explore all 535 Jonathan Swift quotes

More Butchers quotes

Browse all 179 Butchers quotes