Capable Quote by Derrick Bell
“A rule without exceptions is an instrument capable of doing mischief to the innocent and bringing grief - as well as injustice - to those who should gain exemptions from the rule's functioning.”
About This Quote
Source Essay: “The Interest-Convergence Dilemma” by Derrick Bell, 1980
A rigid rule applied without flexibility harms the vulnerable and unfairly penalizes those who deserve leniency.
In simple terms: Strict rules can hurt the innocent and unjustly punish the exempt.
Key Takeaway
Build flexibility into policies.
Themes
justice
fairness
policy
ethics
Mood
concerned
critical
Type
ethical
analytical
When to use this quote
- law enforcement
- education
- healthcare
- social services
- taxation
Key Concepts
Legal theory
social equity
Questions to Reflect On
- How can we balance consistency with compassion?
- Who decides when an exception is justified?
A Different Perspective
Rigid rules may be necessary for consistency, limiting discretion.
![“Harry Belafonte explained: [T]he Second World War happened, and my mother told me that the fight against Hitler was our fight, and I went off, just like that. We were fighting against tyranny, fighting for freedom. But when we-the Black soldiers-came home, we found it was business as usual. There…” quote by Derrick Bell](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/ed7/derrick-bell-16993_parenting_harry-belafonte-explained-t-he-second-wo_528143.jpg)
![“[The Community's] crosses and trials give me confidence. But I derive my hope above all, and most especially, from our utter incapacity, for it is always upon nothingness that God is pleased to rear His works. If at any day we accomplish some good here, the glory will certainly be His alone, since…” quote by Theodore Guerin](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/2b8/theodore-guerin-54729_accomplish_the-community-s-crosses-and-trials-give_7176.jpg)
