Books Quote by Celine Kiernan
““ On the Hunger Games Fan Race fail and the portrayal of POC in fantasy literature : It is as if the POC in the text are walking around with a great big red sign over them for some editors and it reads I AM NOT A REAL CHARACTER. I AM A PROBLEM YOU MUST DEAL WITH. The white characters are permitted to saunter about with their physical descriptions hanging out all over the place, but best not make mention of dark skin or woolly/curly hair or dark eyes (Unless, of course, that character is white. None of my white-skinned dark-eyed characters had any problem being described as such. And I’m pretty sure that Sól’s curly hair never gave anyone a single pause for thought.) As I said, I understand the desire not to define a POC simply by their physical attributes, and I understand cutting physical descriptions if no other character is described physically – but pussyfooting about in this manner with POC is doing nothing but white wash the characters themselves. It’s already much too hard to get readers to latch onto the fact that some characters may not be caucasian, why must we dance about their physical description as if it were some kind of shameful dirty little secret. You know what it reminds me of? It reminds me of the way homosexuality used to only ever be hinted at in texts. It was up to the reader to ‘read between the lines’ or ‘its there if you look for it’ and all that total bullshit which used to be the norm.””
About This Quote
Source Article: Discussion on representation in fantasy literature, author blog, 2023
The quote critiques how people of color are often omitted or minimized in fantasy, treated as problems rather than fully realized characters, while white characters receive detailed physical descriptions.
In simple terms: It points out a double standard in describing characters’ appearances based on race.
Demand authentic, balanced representation of all characters.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- editing guidelines
- author workshops
- reader awareness
- publishing policies
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How can writers describe POC without tokenism?
- What practices ensure equitable character depth?
Overemphasis on physical traits can still reduce characters to stereotypes; nuance is needed.