Good guy Quote by Celine Kiernan
““(CBI lecture, Dublin, 2008. Speaking on the challenges presented by The Moorehawke Trilogy to the YA reader) You can't choose any of these characters and say, 'Yes! I'm completely on your side. You are the good guy! You are the one I agree with.' Because at some stage along the way every single one of these characters will let you down. They may not want to. They may have no choice. But they will let you down.””
About This Quote
Source Lecture: CBI Lecture, Dublin, 2008, discussing The Moorehawke Trilogy
Characters in complex narratives inevitably betray expectations, reflecting nuanced morality and limited agency
In simple terms: Complex characters can disappoint
Key Takeaway
Expect ambiguity and moral conflict
Themes
literature
morality
character development
Mood
reflective
thoughtful
Type
analytical
philosophical
When to use this quote
- reading YA fantasy
- writing character arcs
- teaching moral complexity
- discussing ethical dilemmas
Key Concepts
ethical ambiguity
character agency
narrative complexity
Questions to Reflect On
- How do you reconcile empathy for flawed characters?
- What does betrayal reveal about narrative purpose?
A Different Perspective
Characters may be constrained by plot, limiting true agency
