Administration Quote by Andrew Dickson White
“Persons who clamor for governmental control of American railways should visit Germany, and above all Russia, to see how such control results. In Germany its defects are evident enough; people are made to travel in carriages which our main lines would not think of using, and with a lack of conveniences which with us would provoke a revolt; but the most amazing thing about this administration in Russia is to see how, after all this vast expenditure, the whole atmosphere of the country seems to paralyze energy.”
About This Quote
Source Speech: Address to the American Railway Association, 1885
He argues that state control of railways leads to inefficiency, poor service, and a paralyzing bureaucracy, using Germany and Russia as examples.
In simple terms: Government rail control creates bad service and stagnation.
Key Takeaway
Consider private or mixed ownership models.
Themes
economics
government policy
infrastructure
Mood
skeptical
critical
Type
argumentative
historical
When to use this quote
- policy debates
- transport planning
- business strategy
- public hearings
Key Concepts
central planning
bureaucracy
public vs private ownership
Questions to Reflect On
- What modern examples challenge this view?
- Can regulation improve rail service without stifling innovation?
A Different Perspective
The comparison may be outdated given modern reforms in those countries.
![“Donald Trump can say hey, did she [Hillary Clinton] short-circuit when she reset the relationship with Vladimir Putin and now Russia is, according to "The New York Times" article today, Russia is in control in Syria?” quote by Rudy Giuliani](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/8f8/rudy-giuliani-958_articles_donald-trump-can-say-hey-did-she-hillary_2278059.jpg)
![“The young man [Turgot] destined for an ecclesiastical career was placed within walls carefully designed to keep out all currents of new thought; his studies, his reading, his professors, his associates, all were combined to keep from him any results of observation or reflection save those…” quote by Andrew Dickson White](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/5d4/andrew-dickson-white-24254_associates_the-young-man-turgot-destined-for-an-ecc_3146.jpg)
![“This whole theory [of John Law and Jean Terrasson], as dear to French financial schemers in the eighteenth century as to American "Greenbackers" in the nineteenth, had resulted, under the Orleans Regency and Louis XV, in ruin to France financially and morally, had culminated in the utter…” quote by Andrew Dickson White](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/179/andrew-dickson-white-24254_century_this-whole-theory-of-john-law-and-jean-t_530736.jpg)
![“[Cornell University will be] an asylum for Science—where truth shall be sought for truth's sake, not stretched or cut exactly to fit Revealed Religion.” quote by Andrew Dickson White](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/f23/andrew-dickson-white-24254_cornell_cornell-university-will-be-an-asylum-for_1362392.jpg)
![“His [Turgot's] first important literary and scholastic effort was a treatise On the Existence of God. Few fragments of it remain, but we are helped to understand him when we learn that he asserted, and to the end of his life maintained, his belief in an Almighty Creator and Upholder of the…” quote by Andrew Dickson White](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/9c1/andrew-dickson-white-24254_all-time_his-turgot-s-first-important-literary-an_1733504.jpg)
