Atheism Quote by A.C. Grayling
““I once had a published written debate with a religious apologist who, after I had argued the standard line that the idea of a loving and merciful deity is inconsistent with the fact of natural evil, said this meant his god was not all-powerful, and therefore was not to blame because it could not stop natural evil from occuring. This is a different tack from the more robust one that says natural evil is a response to humanity's moral evil. What this latter view in effect argues is that because of (say) Hitler's wrongdoings, thousands of babies deserve to be drowned in tsunamis.””
About This Quote
Source Book: The God Argument, 2013
He critiques a the that attributes natural evil to human moral evil, arguing it unjustly blames victims for divine inaction.
In simple terms: Questions why suffering is blamed on victims.
Key Takeaway
Challenge the justification of suffering.
Themes
theology
ethics
philosophy
Mood
thoughtful
critical
Type
philosophical
inquisitive
When to use this quote
- debate
- academic discourse
- public speaking
Key Concepts
free will
problem of evil
Questions to Reflect On
- Is suffering always a test of morality?
- Can divine justice be reconciled with natural disasters?
A Different Perspective
Complex theological arguments can oversimplify real pain.
![“The notion that evil is non-rational is a more significant claim for Eagleton than at first appears, because he is (in this book [ On Evil ] as in others of his recent 'late period' prolific burst) anxious to rewrite theology: God (whom he elsewhere tells us is nonexistent, but this is no barrier…” quote by A.C. Grayling](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/6a5/a-c-grayling-9398_atheism_the-notion-that-evil-is-non-rational-is_599668.jpg)
![“If the Irish once find out that there are any circumstances in which they can get free government grants, we shall have a system of mendicancy [begging] such as the world never knew”. After a million had starved to death he stated “The great evil with which we have to contend is not the physical…” quote by Charles Trevelyan](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/83d/charles-trevelyan-72237_begging_if-the-irish-once-find-out-that-there-ar_780001.jpg)
![“Perhaps worse still is what liberal societies might do to themselves in the face of this new and different threat [of terrorism]. They begin, by small but dangerous increments, to cease to be as liberal as they once were. They begin to restrict their own hard-won rights and freedoms as a…” quote by A.C. Grayling](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/42e/a-c-grayling-9398_commit_perhaps-worse-still-is-what-liberal-soci_374837.jpg)
