Skip to content

At the beginning of its treatment of the Ten Commandments…

“At the beginning of its treatment of the Ten Commandments, a rabbinic commentary on Exodus, the Mekilta of Rabbi Ishmael, raises the question why the Ten Commandments did not appear at the beginning of the Torah but appear only in the setting of the introductory words that describe Yahweh as the…” quote by John E. Goldingay
Download Open image
““At the beginning of its treatment of the Ten Commandments, a rabbinic commentary on Exodus, the Mekilta of Rabbi Ishmael, raises the question why the Ten Commandments did not appear at the beginning of the Torah but appear only in the setting of the introductory words that describe Yahweh as the one who brought the people out of Egypt. To what may the matter be compared? To one who came to a province. He said to the people, “May I reign over you?” They said to him, “You have done nothing good for us that we should accept your reign.” What did he do? He built them a wall. He brought them water. He fought battles for them. Then he said to them, “May I reign over you?” They responded, “Yes! Yes!” Thus it was with God. He redeemed Israel from Egypt. He parted the sea for them. He brought them manna. He provided them a well. He sent them quail. He fought the battles of Amalek for them. Then he said to them, “May I reign over you?” They replied, “Yes! Yes!”5 The Mekilta’s theology is closer to that of Paul and of Genesis in implying that it was not the people’s obedience that opened up the possibility of a relationship with Yahweh. Its obedience was a response to Yahweh’s acts.””

John E. Goldingay

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The passage likens God's covenant to a ruler winning acceptance through deeds, suggesting divine actions precede human obedience.

In simple terms: God's actions earn people's willingness to follow.

Key Takeaway

Acts of kindness build trust before authority is accepted.

Themes

faith covenant leadership

Mood

reflective thoughtful

Type

theological philosophical

When to use this quote

  • community building
  • leadership training
  • interfaith dialogue
  • personal faith practice

Key Concepts

theology obedience divine-human relationship

Questions to Reflect On

  • What actions build trust in your relationships?
  • Can authority be accepted without prior deeds?
A Different Perspective

Some may argue obedience should precede divine favor, not the other way.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by John E. Goldingay

Explore all 26 John E. Goldingay quotes

More Abraham quotes

Browse all 484 Abraham quotes