Miss Lucia Alvarez?” she said. “Present,” I answered in…
““Miss Lucia Alvarez?” she said. “Present,” I answered in perfect English. I’d practiced so that there wouldn’t be a trace of a Cuban accent. Mrs. Brolin paused and walked down the aisle toward me. What was she doing? She placed a hand on my shoulder. “Class, I want you all to take notice of Miss Alvarez . . .” Everyone turned in their seats to stare at me. “. . . and help her adjust to life in Nebraska. She’s from Cuba, and I’m sure you have all read in the newspaper about the situation there. If she needs help, I expect all of you to step in and assist her.” Mrs. Brolin patted my shoulder and strutted back to her desk. She was acting all proud of herself. Didn’t she realize that being singled out was the very last thing I wanted? I sank down in my seat, praying that everyone would go back to whatever they were doing before. To my amazement, most of them did. Everyone except a tall boy with freckles who sat closer to the front. He smiled and gave me a little wave. My reaction was to quickly look down at my notebook. When I glanced back, he held up a piece of notebook paper that said, “Hi, I’m Eddie.” I gave him a nod. I was pretty sure that this was not the attention that Mrs. Brolin intended.””
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
A student feels embarrassed when a teacher publicly singles her out as a Cuban immigrant needing help, but a classmate offers genuine friendship instead of pity.
In simple terms: Public shaming versus private kindness; feeling isolated but finding a small ally.
Seek authentic connections, not forced attention.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- school introduction
- new student integration
- peer support
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How can educators support newcomers without singling them out?
- What small actions can peers take to make someone feel welcome?
Some may view public acknowledgment as helpful, but it can also increase stigma.