Barbed wire Quote by Vasily Grossman
““I used to think freedom was freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom of conscience. But freedom is the whole life of everyone. Here is what it amounts to: you have to have the right to sow what you wish to, to make shoes or coats, to bake into bread the flour ground from the grain you have sown, and to sell it or not sell it as you wish; for the lathe operator, the steelworker, and the artist it’s a matter of being able to live as you wish and work as you wish and not as they order you to. And in our country there is no freedom – not for those who write books nor for those who sow grain nor for those who make shoes.” (Grossman, p. 99) He noted that “In people’s day-to-day struggle to live, in the extreme efforts workers put forth to earn an extra ruble through moonlighting, in the collective farmers’ battle for bread and potatoes as the one and only fruit of their labor, he [Ivan Grigoryevich] could sense more than the desire to live better, to fill one’s children’s stomachs and to clothe them. In the battle for the right to make shoes, to knit sweaters, in the struggle to plant what one wished, was manifested the natural, indestructible striving toward freedom inherent in human nature. He had seen this very same struggle in the people in camp. Freedom, it seemed, was immortal on both sides of the barbed wire.” (Grossman, p. 110)””
About This Quote
Source Book: Life and Fate, Vasily Grossman, 1959
Freedom is not just speech or press, but the ability to control one’s work, production, and daily life without external coercion.
In simple terms: Freedom means controlling your work and life.
Seek autonomy in work and daily choices.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- workers seeking extra income
- farmers cultivating crops
- artists creating works
- prisoners under oppression
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How can individuals assert autonomy under oppressive systems?
- What role does economic independence play in true freedom?
Freedom can be limited by state control and economic scarcity.