Buddhism Quote by Sheila Fitzpatrick
““For social pathologies like the Great Purges, there are no fully satisfactory explanations. Every individual knows that he is powerless, an actual or potential victim. It seems impossible, at least to minds brought up on Enlightenment principles, that something so extraordinary, so monstrously outside normal experience, could happen “by accident.” There must be a reason, people think, and yet the thing seems essentially unreasonable, pointless, serving no one’s rational interests. This was basically the framework within which educated, Westernized, modern Russians, members of the elite, understood (or failed to understand) the Great Purges. The dilemma was all the more agonizing in that these were the very people who were most at risk in this round of terror, and knew it. For the majority of the Russian population, less educated and less Westernized, the conceptual problems were not so acute. The terror of 1937–38 was one of those great misfortunes, like war, famine, floods, and pestilence, that periodically afflict mankind and simply have to be endured.””
About This Quote
Source Book: Stalin’s Terror: The Great Purges, 1937‑38, by Sheila Fitzpatrick, 1999
Explains that the Purges defy rational explanation, feeling both powerless and compelled to find meaning in absurd horror.
In simple terms: People seek reasons for irrational evil.
Accept uncertainty, resist false narratives.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- academic study
- public discourse
- personal coping
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- Why do we need explanations for chaos?
- How can societies heal after trauma?
It may underplay individual agency.