Antithesis Quote by Robert Kuttner
“By default, we have created a "system" of nursing-home care for the aged in which middle-class people pay exorbitant rates to for-profit nursing-home entrepreneurs - and then when private resources are consumed and the patient qualifies as a pauper, the nursing home begins billing Medicaid. This is precisely the antithesis of social citizenship; instead of the poor being accorded the dignity associated with the middle class, equality of treatment is achieved by making the middle class undergo pauperization.”
About This Quote
Source Speech: Commentary on US healthcare policy, 2000s
The profit-driven nursing home system forces middle‑class families to pay high fees until patients become poor, then shifts costs to Medicaid, undermining social equality.
In simple terms: Middle‑class pay high rates, then costs shift to public funds for poor patients.
Key Takeaway
Advocate for universal, non‑profit elder care.
Themes
healthcare
inequality
social policy
aging
economics
Mood
concerned
critical
analytical
Type
policy
critique
analysis
When to use this quote
- policy reform
- public advocacy
- elder care budgeting
- tax reform
- insurance design
Key Concepts
profit motive
social citizenship
public funding
Questions to Reflect On
- How can we redesign elder care to avoid class‑based cost shifting?
- What incentives would ensure quality without profit?
A Different Perspective
Profit motives may conflict with quality care and patient dignity.
![“I wrote a comedy, which hopefully [Rick director] Curtiss Clayton will bring to the screen, that I thought was the antithesis of all my work. I thought it was light and sunshiny, and Mr. Clayton reminded me that it is the story of a woman kidnapped and forced to do things against her will, which…” quote by Daniel Handler](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/eda/daniel-handler-1043_antithesis_i-wrote-a-comedy-which-hopefully-rick-di_130261.jpg)
