Cases Quote by Orrin Hatch
“We should evaluate judges and judicial nominees based on the general process for applying the law to any legal disputes, not on the specific result in a particular case or dispute.”
About This Quote
Source Speech: Senate Judiciary Committee hearing, 2005
Judges should be judged by their legal reasoning process, not by outcomes of individual cases.
In simple terms: Judge evaluation should focus on process, not results.
Key Takeaway
Assess judges by fairness and method.
Themes
justice
fairness
legal process
judicial evaluation
Mood
thoughtful
analytical
Type
political
legal
When to use this quote
- court appointments
- legal education
- public opinion
- media coverage
Key Concepts
rule of law
judicial independence
process vs outcome
Questions to Reflect On
- How can we objectively measure a judge's process?
- What safeguards ensure process integrity?
A Different Perspective
Outcomes can reflect bias; process may be opaque.
![“We must use a judicial, rather than a political, standard to evaluate [a nominee's] fitness for the Supreme Court. That standard must be based on the fundamental principle that judges interpret and apply but do not make law.” quote by Orrin Hatch](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/d8b/orrin-hatch-8786_court_we-must-use-a-judicial-rather-than-a-pol_2567435.jpg)
![“[As in the case of] alcohol prohibition, illegality has driven organized crime, sent countless people to jail, and killed many thousands. Repression does not work.” quote by Sam Branson](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/212/sam-branson-36458_alcohol_as-in-the-case-of-alcohol-prohibition-il_8703.jpg)
