Asking Quote by Orrin Hatch
“We must apply a judicial, not a political, standard to this record. Asking a judicial nominee whose side you will be on in future cases is a political standard.”
About This Quote
Source Senate hearing transcript, 2017
The speaker argues that judicial nominations should be evaluated on legal qualifications, not political allegiance, to preserve impartiality.
In simple terms: Judicial appointments must be non‑political.
Prioritize merit over partisanship.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- nomination committees
- public hearings
- media scrutiny
- legal education
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How can we ensure truly impartial judges?
- What safeguards exist against politicized appointments?
Political realities often influence nominations despite ideals.