Skip to content

Abraham Quote by Nigel Warburton

“If Abraham had gone ahead and killed his son he would have done something morally wrong. A father has a basic duty to look after his son, and certainly shouldn't tie him to an altar and cut his throat in a religious ritual. What God asked Abraham to do was to ignore morality and make a leap of…” quote by Nigel Warburton
Download Open image
““If Abraham had gone ahead and killed his son he would have done something morally wrong. A father has a basic duty to look after his son, and certainly shouldn't tie him to an altar and cut his throat in a religious ritual. What God asked Abraham to do was to ignore morality and make a leap of faith. In the Bible Abraham is presented as admirable for ignoring this normal sense of right and wrong and being ready to sacrifice Isaac. But couldn't he have made a terrible mistake? What if the message wasn't really from God? Perhaps it was a hallucination; perhaps Abraham was insane and hearing voices. How could he know for sure? If he had known in advance that God wouldn't follow through on his command, it would have been easy for Abraham. But as he raised that knife ready to shed his son's blood, he really believed that he was going to kill him. That, as the Bible describes the scene, is the point. His faith is so impressive because he put his trust in God rather than in conventional ethical considerations. It wouldn't have been faith otherwise. Faith involves risk. But it is also irrational: not based on reason. Kierkegaard””

Nigel Warburton

About This Quote

Source Book: Kierkegaard’s “Fear and Trembling” (1843)

The passage questions whether Abraham’s willingness to sacrifice Isaac was a moral act or a reckless leap of faith, highlighting the tension between divine command and ethical reasoning.

In simple terms: Abraham’s faith challenges moral norms, risking irrationality.

Key Takeaway

Consider the balance between faith and ethics.

Themes

faith ethics risk religion morality

Mood

thoughtful critical philosophical

Type

philosophical theological controversial

When to use this quote

  • theological debate
  • personal decision-making
  • ethical education

Key Concepts

Divine command irrationality moral dilemma

Questions to Reflect On

  • Is blind obedience ever justified?
  • How do we discern genuine divine guidance?
A Different Perspective

Faith can conflict with rational moral standards, leading to dangerous outcomes.

2.7 out of 5 (8 ratings)

More by Nigel Warburton

Explore all 13 Nigel Warburton quotes

More Abraham quotes

Browse all 484 Abraham quotes