Skip to content

Authority Quote by Nick Harkaway

“This, not incidentally, is another perfect setting for deindividuation: on one side, the functionary behind a wall of security glass following a script laid out with the intention that it should be applied no matter what the specific human story may be, told to remain emotionally disinvested as…” quote by Nick Harkaway
Download Open image
““This, not incidentally, is another perfect setting for deindividuation: on one side, the functionary behind a wall of security glass following a script laid out with the intention that it should be applied no matter what the specific human story may be, told to remain emotionally disinvested as far as possible so as to avoid preferential treatment of one person over another - and needing to follow that advice to avoid being swamped by empathy for fellow human beings in distress. The functionary becomes a mixture of Zimbardo's prison guards and the experimenter himself, under siege from without while at the same time following an inflexible rubric set down by those higher up the hierarchical chain, people whose job description makes them responsible, but who in turn see themselves as serving the general public as a non-specific entity and believe or have been told that only strict adherence to a system can produce impartial fairness. Fairness is supposed to be vested in the code: no human can or should make the system fairer by exercising judgement. In other words, the whole thing creates a collective responsibility culminating in a blameless loop. Everyone assumes that it's not their place to take direct personal responsibility for what happens; that level of vested individual power is part of the previous almost feudal version of responsibility. The deindividuation is actually to a certain extent the desired outcome, though its negative consequences are not.””

Nick Harkaway

About This Quote

Source Book: The Gone-Away World by Nick Harkaway, 2008

Systems that enforce strict, impersonal rules can strip workers of empathy, creating a deindividuated state that masks responsibility and can lead to unfair outcomes.

In simple terms: Rigid rules can desensitize staff, hiding personal accountability.

Key Takeaway

Recognize when rules suppress humanity and intervene.

Themes

bureaucracy deindividuation responsibility fairness empathy

Mood

critical reflective concerned

Type

analytical philosophical

When to use this quote

  • customer service
  • law enforcement
  • healthcare triage
  • judicial sentencing
  • corporate compliance

Key Concepts

social psychology organizational behavior ethical dilemmas

Questions to Reflect On

  • How can organizations balance consistency with compassion?
  • When should discretion override protocol?
A Different Perspective

Over‑reliance on rules can ignore nuanced human needs and cause moral injury.

3.3 out of 5 (5 ratings)

More by Nick Harkaway

Explore all 114 Nick Harkaway quotes

More Authority quotes

Browse all 3,795 Authority quotes