Civilians Quote by Naomi Wolf
“Historically, when a leader has deployed his own military against civilians, it's never been good. There's never been a time where it's ended well.”
About This Quote
Source Speech: Public Lecture on War and Power, 2015
Using a military force against civilians inevitably leads to failure and suffering, showing the moral and strategic flaws of such tactics.
In simple terms: Violent oppression of civilians always ends badly.
Key Takeaway
Avoid using force against non‑combatants.
Themes
ethics
politics
war
leadership
Mood
somber
critical
thoughtful
Type
cautionary
political
ethical
When to use this quote
- policy making
- humanitarian interventions
- peace negotiations
- civil rights advocacy
Key Concepts
state violence
civilian rights
military ethics
Questions to Reflect On
- Is there any scenario where force against civilians could be justified?
- How can leaders protect civilians without military force?
A Different Perspective
Such actions may sometimes be justified by perceived security needs, creating moral dilemmas.
![“We've learned something about President-elect [Donald] Trump's choice for secretary of defense. Lawmakers in Congress intend to proper debate over whether retired General James Mattis meets a requirement for civilian control of the military.” quote by Steve Inskeep](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/6b0/steve-inskeep-10882_choices_we-ve-learned-something-about-president_181750.jpg)
![“The other thing we did as government is to open gates for the civilians to leave that [ eastern part] area [in Aleppo], and at the same time for the humanitarian convoys and help to go through those gates inside that part of Aleppo, but the terrorists publicly refused any solution, so they wanted…” quote by Bashar al-Assad](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/6dc/bashar-al-assad-1027_areas_the-other-thing-we-did-as-government-is_37737.jpg)
![“[General Curtis] LeMay recognized that what he was doing would be thought immoral if his side has lost. But what makes it immoral if you lose and not immoral if you win?” quote by Robert McNamara](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/165/robert-mcnamara-12738_burned_general-curtis-lemay-recognized-that-wha_43443.jpg)
