Skip to content

Federal government Quote by Jonathan Rauch

“The Hayekian position really comes in two quite different versions, one much more sweeping than the other. In its strong version, the Hayekian argument implies that no reforms of long-standing institutions or customs should ever be undertaken, because any legal or political meddling would…” quote by Jonathan Rauch
Download Open image
““The Hayekian position really comes in two quite different versions, one much more sweeping than the other. In its strong version, the Hayekian argument implies that no reforms of long-standing institutions or customs should ever be undertaken, because any legal or political meddling would interfere with the natural evolution of social mores. One would thus have had to say, a century and a half ago, that slavery should not be forcibly abolished, because it was customary in almost all human societies. More recently, one would have had to say that the federal government was wrong to step in and end racial segregation instead of letting it evolve at its own pace. Obviously, neither Hayek nor any reputable follower of his would defend every cultural practice simply on the grounds that it must exist for a reason. Hayekians would point out that slavery violated a fundamental tenet of justice and was intolerably cruel. In calling for slavery’s abolition, they do what must be done if they are to be human: they establish a moral standpoint from which to judge social rules and reforms. They thus acknowledge that sometimes society must make changes in the name of fairness or decency, even if there are bound to be hidden costs. ... Hayek himself, then, was a partisan of the milder version of Hayekianism. This version is not so much a prescription as an attitude. Respect tradition. Reject utopianism. Plan for mistakes rather than for perfection. If reform is needed, look for paths that follow the terrain of custom, if possible. If someone promises to remake society on rational or supernatural or theological principles, run in the opposite direction. In sum: move ahead, but be careful.””

Jonathan Rauch

About This Quote

Source Book: The World According to Hayek, 2005

Hayek’s moderate view respects tradition but allows reforms for justice, avoiding rigid conservatism.

In simple terms: Balance tradition with needed change for fairness.

Key Takeaway

Respect customs, but correct injustices.

Themes

politics ethics tradition reform pragmatism

Mood

critical analytical

Type

philosophical inspirational

When to use this quote

  • legislation
  • civil rights
  • economic policy
  • social movements

Key Concepts

social evolution justice policy incremental change

Questions to Reflect On

  • What customs should be reexamined today?
  • How can reforms honor tradition while advancing justice?
A Different Perspective

Rigid adherence to tradition can perpetuate harm.

3.5 out of 5 (4 ratings)

More by Jonathan Rauch

Explore all 29 Jonathan Rauch quotes

More Federal government quotes

Browse all 1,120 Federal government quotes