Skip to content

Agree Quote by Janet Scudder

“Someone has said that even criticism is better than silence. I don't agree to this. Criticism can be very harmful unless it comes from a master; and in spite of the fact that we have hundreds of critics these days, it is one of the most difficult of professions.” quote by Janet Scudder
Download Open image
“Someone has said that even criticism is better than silence. I don't agree to this. Criticism can be very harmful unless it comes from a master; and in spite of the fact that we have hundreds of critics these days, it is one of the most difficult of professions.”

Janet Scudder

About This Quote

A critique of indiscriminate criticism, arguing that only expert feedback is constructive, while casual critics often lack depth and can cause harm.

In simple terms: Constructive criticism

Key Takeaway

Expertise matters in feedback

Themes

Criticism Expertise Communication Professionalism

Mood

Critical Cautious

Type

Philosophical Professional advice

When to use this quote

  • Creative industries
  • Academic peer review
  • Workplace performance reviews

Key Concepts

Feedback quality Authority Impact of words

Practical Applications

  • Mentorship programs
  • Professional development workshops

Questions to Reflect On

  • When does criticism become harmful?
  • How can we differentiate expert feedback from noise?
A Different Perspective

Criticism, even from experts, can still be biased or discouraging.

3.1 out of 5 (3 ratings)

More by Janet Scudder

Explore all 3 Janet Scudder quotes

More Agree quotes

Browse all 3,079 Agree quotes