Assumption Quote by James M. Buchanan
“The assumption that we can keep societies open and free to everybody is going to have to stop. We are going to have to recognize that some people simply are not qualified and do not want to belong a civil order. Until we begin to make discrimination along those lines, then I think we are going to be extremely vulnerable.”
About This Quote
Source Speech: Public Policy Lecture, 1998
Societies must limit membership to those willing and able to uphold civil order, otherwise they become vulnerable to breakdown.
In simple terms: Open societies need qualified, willing participants to stay stable.
Key Takeaway
Recognize and enforce standards for civic participation.
Themes
civic responsibility
social cohesion
exclusion
vulnerability
Mood
concerned
critical
Type
political
ethical
When to use this quote
- immigration policy
- citizen vetting
- community safety
- government regulation
Key Concepts
political theory
social contract
risk management
Questions to Reflect On
- Who decides qualification for civic membership?
- How to balance inclusion with security?
A Different Perspective
Exclusion can lead to discrimination and loss of diversity.
