Skip to content

Christianity Quote by James K.A. Smith

“But should we accept this negative view of power? Is power all bad? Specifically, can Christians share in this devaluation of power and discipline as inherently evil? Can we who claim to be disciples - who are called and predestined to be conformed to the likeness of the Son (Rom. 8:29) - be…” quote by James K.A. Smith
Download Open image
““But should we accept this negative view of power? Is power all bad? Specifically, can Christians share in this devaluation of power and discipline as inherently evil? Can we who claim to be disciples - who are called and predestined to be conformed to the likeness of the Son (Rom. 8:29) - be opposed to discipline and formation as such? Can we who are called to be subject to the Lord of life really agree with the liberal Enlightenment notion of the autonomous self? Are we not above all called to subject ourselves to our Domine and conform to his image? Of course, we are called not to conform to the patterns of 'this world' (Rom. 12:2) or to our previous evil desires (1 Peter 1:14), but that is a call not to nonconformity as such but rather to an alternative conformity through a counterformation in Christ, a transformation and renewal directed toward conformity to his image. By appropriating the liberal Enlightenment notion of negative freedom and participating in its nonconformist resistance to discipline (and hence a resistance to the classical spiritual disciplines), Christians are in fact being conformed to the patterns of this world (contra Rom. 12:2).””

James K.A. Smith

About This Quote

Source Book: Who Needs a Soul? by James K.A. Smith, 2009

The quote challenges the view that power and discipline are inherently evil, urging Christians to embrace disciplined formation toward Christ’s likeness rather than liberal notions of autonomous self‑determination.

In simple terms: Christians should see power and discipline as tools for spiritual formation, not as evil.

Key Takeaway

Embrace disciplined formation toward Christ’s image.

Themes

theiritual formation power discipline autonomy conformity

Mood

reflective serious inquisitive

Type

theilosophical theological

When to use this quote

  • church leadership
  • personal spiritual practice
  • education
  • counseling
  • public policy

Key Concepts

Theology Christian ethics Enlightenment critique

Questions to Reflect On

  • How can disciplined formation coexist with personal freedom?
  • What does “counter‑formation” look like in daily life?
A Different Perspective

Liberal individualism can undermine communal responsibility and spiritual growth.

2.2 out of 5 (6 ratings)

More by James K.A. Smith

Explore all 60 James K.A. Smith quotes

More Christianity quotes

Browse all 14,385 Christianity quotes