Poor planning Quote by J.M. Redmann
![“All the rainbow banners were still there; the storm [Katrina] had left them intact. Interesting that the gay and bawdy sections of town were the parts least damaged, since some of the so-called religious people were claiming this to be God's punishment for our sinful ways. Perhaps they believed in…” quote by J.M. Redmann](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/e9f/j-m-redmann-46730_poor-planning_all-the-rainbow-banners-were-still-there_1105010.jpg)
““All the rainbow banners were still there; the storm [Katrina] had left them intact. Interesting that the gay and bawdy sections of town were the parts least damaged, since some of the so-called religious people were claiming this to be God's punishment for our sinful ways. Perhaps they believed in a god of poor planning.””
About This Quote
Source Speech: Interview on Hurricane Katrina aftermath, 2005
The quote highlights the irony that areas known for nightlife survived while religious critics blamed the disaster on moral failings, suggesting a flawed divine rationale.
In simple terms: Survivors of disaster challenge simplistic blame on morality.
Key Takeaway
Question assumptions about divine punishment.
Themes
irony
faith
disaster
social judgment
Mood
reflective
critical
skeptical
Type
observational
social commentary
When to use this quote
- post‑disaster relief
- community rebuilding
- media commentary
Key Concepts
theodicy
human resilience
cultural bias
Questions to Reflect On
- How do we avoid moralizing tragedy?
- What evidence counters the “punishment” narrative?
A Different Perspective
Relies on anecdotal observation, may not represent broader patterns.
