Brain Quote by J. J. C. Smart
“Indeterminism does not confer freedom on us: I would feel that my freedom was impaired if I thought that a quantum mechanical trigger in my brain might cause me to leap into the garden and eat a slug”
About This Quote
Source Book: Philosophy of Mind, 1976
Deterministic quantum events in the brain do not grant free will; freedom requires more than random triggers.
In simple terms: Random brain events don’t equal freedom.
Key Takeaway
Seek agency beyond chance.
Themes
free will
determinism
quantum mechanics
Mood
analytical
inquisitive
Type
philosophical
theoretical
When to use this quote
- ethical decision making
- personal responsibility
- scientific research
- legal accountability
Key Concepts
causality
agency
philosophy of mind
Questions to Reflect On
- Does randomness diminish moral responsibility?
- Can free will exist in a deterministic framework?
A Different Perspective
Randomness can undermine accountability if misinterpreted.
