Anti-catholicism Quote by G.K. Chesterton
““Does the reader realise the despair that falls upon the hapless Catholic journalist at such moments; or how wild a prayer he may well send up for the intercession of St. Francis of Sales? What is he to say; or at what end of that sentence is he to begin? What is the good of his laboriously beginning to explain that a married clergy is a matter of discipline and not doctrine, that it can therefore be allowed locally without heresy--when all the time the man thinks a beard as important as a wife and more important than a false religion? What is the sense of explaining to him the peculiar historical circumstances that have led to preserving some local habits in Kiev or Warsaw, when the man at any moment may receive a mortal shock by seeing a bearded Franciscan walking through Wimbledon or Walham Green? What we want to get at is the mind of the man who can think so absurdly about us as to suppose we could have a horror of heresy, and then a weakness for heresy, and then a greater horror of hair. To what does he attribute all the inconsistent nonsense and inconsequent bathos that he associates with us? Does he think we are all joking; or all dreaming; or all out of our minds; or what does he think?””
About This Quote
Source Essay: Orthodoxy, 1908
The writer satirizes a Catholic journalist’s confusion over clerical marriage, exposing the absurdity of conflating doctrine with discipline and the irrational fear of heresy.
In simple terms: A journalist is confused about Catholic rules and fears heresy.
Question assumptions about religious discipline.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- church debates
- media coverage
- interfaith dialogue
- personal belief crises
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How do personal biases shape our view of religious practices?
- What role does humor play in critiquing doctrine?
The satire may oversimplify complex theological debates.