Disadvantage Quote by G.K. Chesterton
““A real problem only occurs when there are admittedly disadvantages in all courses that can be pursued. If it is discovered just before a fashionable wedding that the Bishop is locked up in the coal-cellar, that is not a problem. It is obvious to anyone but an extreme anti-clerical or practical joker that the Bishop must be let out of the coal-cellar. But suppose the Bishop has been locked up in the wine-cellar, and from the obscure noises, sounds as of song and dance, etc., it is guessed that he has indiscreetly tested the vintages round him; then indeed we may properly say that there has arisen a problem; for upon the one hand, it is awkward to keep the wedding waiting, while, upon the other, any hasty opening of the door might mean an episcopal rush and scenes of the most unforeseen description.””
About This Quote
Source Novel: The Man Who Was Thursday by G.K. Chesterton, 1908
A problem arises only when every possible solution has a drawback, creating a dilemma between urgency and caution.
In simple terms: Problems appear when all options have flaws.
Key Takeaway
Weigh urgency against consequences.
Themes
dilemma
urgency
consequences
decisionmaking
Mood
anxious
reflective
Type
philosophical
humorous
When to use this quote
- wedding planning
- crisis management
- legal decisions
- event coordination
Key Concepts
ethical paradox
practical constraints
Questions to Reflect On
- What trade‑off is acceptable in urgent crises?
- How do you prioritize competing risks?
A Different Perspective
If the bishop is released hastily, unintended chaos may follow.
