Skip to content

Dirty dishes Quote by Ellen Ullman

“IV. Real techies don’t worry about forced eugenics. I learned this from a real techie in the cafeteria of a software company. The project team is having lunch and discussing how long it would take to wipe out a disease inherited recessively on the X chromosome. First come calculations of…” quote by Ellen Ullman
Download Open image
““IV. Real techies don’t worry about forced eugenics. I learned this from a real techie in the cafeteria of a software company. The project team is having lunch and discussing how long it would take to wipe out a disease inherited recessively on the X chromosome. First come calculations of inheritance probabilities. Given a population of a given size, one of the engineers arrives at a wipe-out date. Immediately another suggests that the date could be moved forward by various manipulations of the inheritance patterns. For example, he says, there could be an education campaign. The six team members then fall over one another with further suggestions. They start with rewards to discourage carriers from breeding. Immediately they move to fines for those who reproduce the disease. Then they go for what they call “more effective” measures: Jail for breeding. Induced abortion. Forced sterilization. Now they’re hot. The calculations are flying. Years and years fall from the final doom-date of the disease. Finally, they get to the ultimate solution. “It’s straightforward,” someone says. “Just kill every carrier.” Everyone responds to this last suggestion with great enthusiasm. One generation and—bang—the disease is gone. Quietly, I say, “You know, that’s what the Nazis did.” They all look at me in disgust. It’s the look boys give a girl who has interrupted a burping contest. One says, “This is something my wife would say.” When he says “wife,” there is no love, warmth, or goodness in it. In this engineer’s mouth, “wife” means wet diapers and dirty dishes. It means someone angry with you for losing track of time and missing dinner. Someone sentimental. In his mind (for the moment), “wife” signifies all programming-party-pooping, illogical things in the universe. Still, I persist. “It started as just an idea for the Nazis, too, you know.” The engineer makes a reply that sounds like a retch. “This is how I know you’re not a real techie,” he says.””

Ellen Ullman

About This Quote

Source Short Story: “The Real Techies,” Ellen Ullman, 2004

The discussion of extreme genetic solutions reveals how quickly ethical lines blur when faced with a problem, echoing dangerous historical precedents.

In simple terms: Tech debates can slide into immoral ideas quickly.

Key Takeaway

Question the morality of radical solutions.

Themes

ethics science genetics history power danger

Mood

cautionary critical serious

Type

ethical political historical

When to use this quote

  • policy making
  • genetic research
  • public health debates
  • technology development

Key Concepts

bioethics utilitarianism historical memory

Questions to Reflect On

  • What safeguards prevent scientific hubris?
  • How do we balance urgency with moral responsibility?
A Different Perspective

Enthusiasm for quick fixes can ignore human rights and past atrocities.

4.5 out of 5 (4 ratings)

More by Ellen Ullman

Explore all 119 Ellen Ullman quotes

More Dirty dishes quotes

Browse all 34 Dirty dishes quotes