Financial independence Quote by Edouard Berth
““Compare, for example, seventeenth century writers with those of the eighteenth. What a difference in tone and gait! The former, under a veneer of servility, have the most noble and proud stance… They do not pretend to reign. They merely stand at their place, recognize the place of a superior power beyond, give themselves completely to their writing task, dismiss the temptation of advertising and demonstrate their professional dedication. On the other hand, look at the Voltaire, Diderot and the like: they open well the era of intellectuals, writing stooges as they are, courtiers of princes they flatter and despise at the same time—something they are forced to do as they want to usurp their power… Their courtier nature reveals in everything they do… The whole eighteenth century, both spiritual and plain on a scoundrel background, is libertine, and already pornographic: such is the start of literary mercantilism; people of letters make money out of their writings, pretend to financial independence, and they write garbage to flatter the opinion of their public.””
About This Quote
Source Essay: Literary Critique, 19th Century, 1885
The author contrasts 17th‑century writers' humble dedication with 18th‑century authors' commercial motives and superficiality.
In simple terms: Contrast between sincere dedication and commercial pretension.
Value authentic commitment over profit‑driven writing.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- academic lectures
- book reviews
- teaching literature
- publishing decisions
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- Do you think any 18th‑century writers were truly sincere?
- How does commercial pressure affect modern creators?
The view may oversimplify complex historical contexts.