Biology Quote by David Berlinski
““Before you can ask 'Is Darwinian theory correct or not?', You have to ask the preliminary question 'Is it clear enough so that it could be correct?'. That's a very different question. One of my prevailing doctrines about Darwinian theory is 'Man, that thing is just a mess. It's like looking into a room full of smoke.' Nothing in the theory is precisely, clearly, carefully defined or delineated. It lacks all of the rigor one expects from mathematical physics, and mathematical physics lacks all the rigor one expects from mathematics. So we're talking about a gradual descent down the level of intelligibility until we reach evolutionary biology.””
About This Quote
Source Book: The Devil's Delusion by David Berlinski, 2008
The quote argues that before evaluating Darwinian theory, we must first assess whether it is clearly defined enough to be testable, noting its lack of rigorous, mathematical precision.
In simple terms: We need clear, rigorous definitions before judging a theory.
Key Takeaway
Demand precise, testable definitions in scientific theories.
Themes
science philosophy
evolution
methodology
Mood
critical
inquisitive
Type
analytical
philosophical
When to use this quote
- academic debate
- science education
- public policy
- research design
Key Concepts
epistemology
rigor
clarity
Questions to Reflect On
- How can we improve clarity in evolutionary explanations?
- Is some vagueness acceptable in complex sciences?
A Different Perspective
The complexity of biology may resist full mathematical formalism, limiting precision.
![“Natural selection eliminates and maybe maintains, but it doesn't create... Neo-Darwinists say that new species emerge when mutations occur and modify an organism. I was taught over and over again that the accumulation of random mutations led to evolutionary change [which] led to new species. I…” quote by Lynn Margulis](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/5b9/lynn-margulis-17073_biology_natural-selection-eliminates-and-maybe-m_397958.jpg)
![“Whatever the degree to which Darwin may have “misled science into a dead end,” the biologist Shi V. Liu observed in commenting on Koonin’s paper, “we may still appreciate the role of Darwin in helping scientists [win an] upper hand in fighting against the creationists.” quote by David Berlinski](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/0de/david-berlinski-16009_dead-end_whatever-the-degree-to-which-darwin-may_342124.jpg)
