Aptitude Quote by Daniel Seligman
“Once again the Naderites were onstage attacking the Educational Testing Service - the organization which develops and administers the scholastic aptitude tests...the reason for the wax is that the E.T.S. tests persist in showing some people to be smarter than others. And if some people are smarter than others, there might actually be some justification for an economic system in which some people have more money and authority than others.”
About This Quote
Source Speech: Public lecture on education policy, date unknown
The quote critiques standardized testing for reinforcing social hierarchies and justifying economic inequality.
In simple terms: Tests can reinforce inequality and justify wealth gaps.
Key Takeaway
Question the fairness of tests and their societal impact.
Themes
education
inequality
meritocracy
economics
Mood
critical
reflective
Type
analytical
political
When to use this quote
- policy debate
- school admissions
- employment screening
- public discourse
Key Concepts
social stratification
meritocratic myth
testing bias
Questions to Reflect On
- How do tests shape perceptions of intelligence?
- What alternatives could reduce inequality?
A Different Perspective
Tests may not fully measure ability and can be biased.
![“Standardization of our educational systems [which includes testing]is apt to stamp out individualism and defeat the very ends of education by leveling the product down rather than up.” quote by Harvey Cushing](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/aff/harvey-cushing-45699_defeat_standardization-of-our-educational-syste_1569232.jpg)
![“I think [testing] has had a profoundly problematic impact on student learning. It must seem to students that their worth as individuals is equivalent to their test score. The stress the high stakes culture has on teachers is also highly negative and must surely impact students in a negative way…” quote by Carol Ann Tomlinson](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/94d/carol-ann-tomlinson-15427_culture_i-think-testing-has-had-a-profoundly-pro_392424.jpg)
![“The meeting [in San Antonio of the National Women's Political Caucus] featured a cattle show at which a herd of Democratic candidates- Glenn, Cranston, Mondale, Hart, and Hollings- pantingly pantomined their fidelity to feminism, stopping just short of a pledge to use nuclear weapons against any…” quote by Daniel Seligman](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/d1b/daniel-seligman-65571_amendments_the-meeting-in-san-antonio-of-the-nation_412863.jpg)
![“Net result [of the Dept. of Agriculture's Payment in Kind - PIK - program]: total farm income, now expected to be around $25 billion, this fiscal year, will exceed total federal subsidies by only a couple of billion. You could argue that those fellows out there on the fruited plain are in effect…” quote by Daniel Seligman](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/b77/daniel-seligman-65571_administration_net-result-of-the-dept-of-agriculture-s_1757219.jpg)
![“The first [quality] to be named must always be the power of attention, of giving one's whole mind to the patient without the interposition of anything of oneself. It sounds simple but only the very greatest doctors ever fully attain it. ... The second thing to be striven for is intuition. This…” quote by Wilfred Trotter](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/e2d/wilfred-trotter-30944_aptitude_the-first-quality-to-be-named-must-alway_74426.jpg)
